Skip to content
GanttPal
Log in Get started

Leadership vs. Management for Project Managers

Project managers are often judged on delivery, yet the work that makes delivery possible is relational. This episode summary from a conversation between Susanne Madsen, author of The Power of Project Leadership, and Brett Harned explores that distinction — and the habits that help a project manager move from coordinating work to leading the people who do it.

Tasks are managed; people are led

A useful shorthand runs through the episode: you manage tasks but you lead people. Management answers questions about what needs to happen, in what order, and by when. Leadership answers questions about how people experience working together — whether they feel heard, trusted and clear enough to do their best work.

That shift is practical, not theoretical. Two project managers can hold the same plan and produce very different team climates. One treats every interaction as a status check. The other notices stress early, regulates their own reaction, and creates space for honest discussion about risks. The second approach depends less on authority and more on attitude, behaviour and emotional intelligence.

A quick self-check for project managers

Use this check when a week feels busy but not effective:

  • People check: Did I spend time this week understanding concerns, not only collecting updates?
  • Emotion check: Did I pause and regulate my own response before reacting in a meeting or message?
  • Important-work check: Did planning, risk discussion and agreeing how the team works get protected time, or did urgent requests consume the day?
  • Expertise check: Did I ask questions and listen, rather than trying to demonstrate that I already know the answer?
  • Feedback check: Have I asked a respected colleague what I should start, stop and continue doing?

If several answers are no, the pattern is usually one of the three mistakes below — not a lack of effort.

Three mistakes that keep project managers from leading

First, task focus can crowd out people focus. Keeping the plan moving matters, but when every conversation is about deliverables, relationships weaken and problems surface late. The alternative is deliberate relationship-building: listening, following through, and managing your own emotions so others can think clearly.

Second, urgent work can crowd out important work. Firefighting may feel heroic in the moment, yet it repeatedly displaces planning, risk work and agreeing how the team will operate. A leader protects time for prevention, even when immediate requests are louder.

Third, trying to know and do it all undermines credibility rather than building it. A project manager needs enough subject-matter understanding to ask informed questions and challenge assumptions. Beyond that point, listening and asking are stronger moves than performing expertise.

Small practices that build leadership

Growth in this area does not require a new title. The episode points to small, repeatable practices: ask more open questions, listen for what is not being said, and invite specific feedback using a start, stop and continue format. Asking people you respect — not only your manager — widens the picture and makes blind spots easier to correct.

The conversation also covers the path to leadership, encouraging leadership in others, and finding time to level up. Those themes connect to Madsen's book, The Power of Project Leadership, discussed as being in its second edition and up for a PMI award at the time of the episode.

About this episode

Episode 22 of the Time Limit podcast, published 11 November 2019, runs about 36 minutes. Resources discussed include The Power of Project Leadership and Susanne Madsen's website. Related episodes listed alongside it are Episode 21 on managing design process with Paul Boag and Episode 20 on motivation with Ruth Pearce.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between managing tasks and leading people?

Task management concerns schedules, deliverables and coordination. Leading people concerns how you show up with others — your attitude, behaviour and emotional intelligence. A project manager does both, but leadership is not conferred by a job title.

What three mistakes keep project managers from leading?

The conversation highlights three common traps: focusing on tasks instead of people, chasing urgent firefighting instead of important work, and assuming you must know and do everything yourself. Counter-moves include regulating your emotions, building relationships, protecting time for planning and risk work, knowing enough to ask good questions, and listening more.

How can a project manager grow leadership skills quickly?

Ask more open questions, and ask people you respect what you should start, stop and continue doing. That feedback loop makes growth concrete instead of abstract.